Previously: Kan extensions in Haskell.

In a double category that is also a proarrow equipment, we have the ability to bend arrows. In particular, in the definition of the counit of the right Kan extension:

we can bend the vertical j arrow, replacing it with its horizontal conjoint B(1, j). In a profunctor equipment, this is just a representable profunctor \langle b, a\rangle \mapsto B(b, j a).

A natural generalization is to replace this representable with a general profunctor. This way we get a definition of a right Kan extension along a profunctor J.

In a more general setting of a double category, the counit of the right Kan extension is a 2-cell:

The universal condition can be similarly generalized by bending the j arrows.

However, the universal condition for pointwise right Kan extensions is stronger. It involves an additional horizontal 1-cell H. It states that any 2-cell \phi of the shape below can be uniquely factorized through the counit \epsilon:

Right Kan extensions in Haskell

In Haskell, the right Kan extension of a functor d along a profunctor j can be written as a data type:

newtype Ran j d a = Ran (forall x . j a x -> d x)

This is a direct translation of the categorical formula that uses an end:

(\text{Ran}_J d) \, a = \int_x \text{Set}(J a x, d \, x)

Compare this with the earlier implementation of the Kan extension, in which j was a functor:

newtype Ran j d a = Ran (forall x . (a -> j x) -> d x)

The counit is a 2-cell from j to the identity profunctor (->):

epsilon :: (Profunctor j, Functor d) => 
  Cell (Ran j d) d j (->)
epsilon jab (Ran ran) = ran jab

The 2-cell Phi goes from the profunctor composition of j and h to the identity profunctor:

type Phi s d j h  = Cell s d (Procompose j h) (->)

The factorization cell Phi' goes from h to identity:

type Phi' s d j h = Cell s (Ran j d) h (->)

For any Phi, we can find the corresponding Phi':

rightAdj :: (Profunctor j, Profunctor h, Functor d, Functor s) =>
        Phi s d j h -> Phi' s d j h
rightAdj phi hac sa = Ran (\ jcb -> phi (Procompose jcb hac) sa)

This function replaces the right adjoint used in the traditional definition of a Kan extension.

The result satisfies the factorization property:

factor :: (Profunctor j, Profunctor h, Functor d, Functor s) => 
  Phi s d j h -> Phi s d j h
factor phi = funComp . vcomp (rightAdj phi) epsilon

Here vcomp is the vertical composition of 2-cells:

vcomp :: (Functor f, Functor g, Functor h
         , Profunctor p, Profunctor q, Profunctor r, Profunctor s) =>
  Cell f g p r -> Cell g h q s 
  -> Cell f h (Procompose q p) (Procompose s r)
vcomp fg_pr gh_qs (Procompose qxc pax) 
    = Procompose (gh_qs qxc) (fg_pr pax)

and funComp is hom-functor composition:

funComp :: Procompose (->) (->) a b -> (a -> b)
funComp (Procompose f g) = f . g

The computational meaning of the universal construction is that, in order to define a 2-cell (natural transformation) from some functor s to Ran j d along a profunctor h, it’s enough to provide a 2-cell from s to d along a composite Procompose j h.

Left Kan extensions

We can apply similar generalization to left Kan extensions. This time we start with the unit given by the 2-cell:

The universal condition that defines the pointwise left Kan extension of a vertical 1-cell d along a horizontal 1-cell J is given by the following unique factorization:

Left Kan extensions in Haskell

In Haskell, we define the left Kan extension along a profunctor as an existential data type:

data Lan j d a where
    Lan :: j x a -> d x -> Lan j d a

This is a direct translation of the coend formula:

(\text{Lan}_J d)\, a = \int^x ( J x a \times d \,x)

The unit is a 2-cell:

eta :: (Profunctor j, Functor d) => Cell d (Lan j d) j (->)
eta jab da = Lan jab da

The universal condition states that, for any 2-cell:

type Phi s d j h  = Cell d s (Procompose h j) (->)

there is a unique 2-cell:

type Phi' s d j h = Cell (Lan j d) s h (->)

given by the mapping:

leftAdj :: (Profunctor j, Profunctor h, Functor d, Functor s) =>
        Phi s d j h -> Phi' s d j h
leftAdj phi hac (Lan jxa dx) = phi (Procompose hac jxa) dx

that uniquely factorizes through the unit eta:

factor :: (Profunctor j, Profunctor h, Functor d, Functor s) =>
    Phi s d j h -> Phi s d j h
factor phi = funComp . vcomp eta (leftAdj phi)

Again, computationally, this defines a mapping-out property of the left Kan extension.

Complete Haskell code is available here: left Kan extensions, right Kan extensions.